top of page
Search

Guide to Bathtub and Shower Surround Materials: Pros, Cons & What to Choose

  • Ben
  • May 12
  • 3 min read

Choosing the right material for your bathtub, bath surround, or shower surround is one of the most important decisions during a bathroom remodel. Beyond aesthetics, your selection impacts durability, maintenance, comfort, and cost. In this guide, we break down the most common materials used for tubs and surrounds—including what you’ll spend and what to expect long-term.


Bathroom Remodel in Palmyra, PA
Bathroom Remodel in Palmyra, PA

Bathtub Materials


1. Acrylic

  • Overview: Lightweight and affordable, acrylic tubs are molded plastic reinforced with fiberglass.

  • Pros: Warm to the touch, easy to clean, resists chipping, good insulation.

  • Cons: Can scratch more easily than harder surfaces.

  • Best For: Budget-conscious homeowners wanting modern looks and comfort.


2. Fiberglass (FRP)

  • Overview: A lower-cost alternative to acrylic, made from reinforced plastic.

  • Pros: Very affordable, lightweight, easy to install.

  • Cons: Less durable, prone to scratching, fading, and cracking over time.

  • Best For: Quick flips, rental properties, or short-term use.


3. Cast Iron with Enamel Coating

  • Overview: Heavy-duty tubs made from cast iron and coated with porcelain enamel.

  • Pros: Extremely durable, retains heat well, classic appearance.

  • Cons: Very heavy (may require floor reinforcement), higher cost.

  • Best For: Traditional-style homes or homeowners who want long-term performance.


4. Solid Surface / Cultured Stone

  • Overview: Made from resin and natural stone powders, often used in premium designs.

  • Pros: Sleek look, seamless design, durable, non-porous.

  • Cons: Higher cost, limited availability in some areas.

  • Best For: High-end bathrooms seeking luxury aesthetics and low maintenance.


5. Copper or Stone

  • Overview: High-end and often custom tubs made from materials like copper, marble, or granite.

  • Pros: Unique appearance, luxurious feel, highly durable (especially copper).

  • Cons: Very expensive, heavy, may require special care.

  • Best For: Statement pieces or luxury custom bathrooms.


Bath & Shower Surround Materials


1. Tile (Ceramic, Porcelain, or Natural Stone)

  • Overview: A classic choice that allows for custom design and pattern work.

  • Pros: Highly customizable, great visual impact, durable when installed properly.

  • Cons: Grout requires maintenance; more expensive to install than prefabricated panels.

  • Best For: Custom showers or high-style bathrooms with good ventilation.


2. Acrylic Surrounds

  • Overview: Pre-fabricated panels that are installed directly over walls.

  • Pros: Easy to clean, affordable, quick installation.

  • Cons: Fewer design options, lower-end appearance than tile or stone.

  • Best For: Budget-friendly or time-sensitive projects.


3. Fiberglass / Gelcoat

  • Overview: Common in one-piece or multi-piece shower units.

  • Pros: Inexpensive, lightweight, easy to install.

  • Cons: Less durable, prone to yellowing and scratching over time.

  • Best For: Basic remodels, rental units, or basements.


4. Solid Surface / Engineered Stone

  • Overview: Made from synthetic materials like cultured marble or quartz composites.

  • Pros: Seamless, easy to clean, water-resistant, upscale look.

  • Cons: Higher price point than acrylic or fiberglass.

  • Best For: Mid- to high-end remodels where low maintenance and sleek design are priorities.


5. Glass Panels (for Showers)

  • Overview: Frameless or semi-frameless panels used for shower enclosures.

  • Pros: Modern look, opens up visual space, easy to clean with proper coating.

  • Cons: More expensive than a standard shower curtain or framed enclosure, may require custom fitting.

  • Best For: Contemporary bathrooms and walk-in showers.


How to Choose the Right Material for You


Ask yourself:

  • What’s your budget?

  • How long do you plan to live in the home?

  • Do you want low maintenance or are you okay with some upkeep like grout cleaning?

  • Is this a statement design or a practical remodel?


If you're unsure, we recommend choosing materials that balance durability, appearance, and ease of maintenance—especially in moisture-heavy spaces like bathrooms.


Need Help Picking the Right Material?


At Ebersole Remodeling, we help homeowners choose the best materials for their needs, style, and budget. Whether you're upgrading a shower or planning a full bath remodel, we’ll guide you from concept to completion.


Comments

bottom of page